The proposal to overturn the moratorium on commercial whaling has been withdrawn, preserving the long-standing ban. This article explores the implications of this decision and the ongoing challenges faced by the whaling industry and conservation efforts.
Preventing the Resumption of Commercial Whaling
A long-running effort to mitigate the moratorium on commercial whaling that has been in place for more than four decades failed ahead of a crucial vote at the International Whaling Commission (IWC) meeting being held in Lima, the capital city and loneliest desert capital in South America. For conservationists, the decision is a welcome one after decades of trying to stop whalers from killing the largest creature on Earth.
The moratorium has been an essential guardian against the overexploitation of whales since it was introduced in 1986. However, some countries like Japan have continued to hunt whales under the pretense of scientific research and have drawn wide criticism from the international society. This even shows a continuous battle to apply the principle of sustainable and responsible management of marine resources.
The Japan Connection and Food Security
A second motion to label all whaling as a matter of global food security went the same way during the IWC gathering. It was this proposal — made by a group of African countries — that NGOs believed Japan was using to try to keep its foot in the door at the commission even after it left the IWC last year.
The fact that Japan is still pushing to end the whaling ban is a clear example of how political dynamics play into global conservation. Other nations, especially those with limited resources, have a fear that the first might exploit the marine resources for political and economic manipulation rather than true intentions towards food security emissions.
A more comprehensive and just way to combat the challenges: a yet-in-depth approach that promotes sustainability and understands how to protect our oceans right.
Conclusion
The proposals to lift the long-standing ban on commercial whaling and to brand whaling a humanitarian issue affirming that it is “critical to global food security,” will not be considered by the panel in what represents a major victory for marine conservation. But as long as pro-whaling interests wield influence, and new threats such as climate change continue to loom over vulnerable whale populations, the battle rages on. These are complex challenges as the international community continues to grapple with them and policymakers and stakeholders need to collaborate towards finding a balanced, sustainable solution for the good of whales and our oceans.
